Picture on this debate

‘Guvernance’ and the ‘role’ of law: Getting the vowels right

Following on the release of the World Bank's latest report on governance, Richard Sannerholm takes a closer look at the difference between the 'role' of and 'rule' of law in the latest Justice and Peace blog series entry, defending the importance of the rule of law in today's political climate.

Profile picture of Richard Sannerholm

Discussion started by
Richard Sannerholm

Swedish Expert Group for Aid Studies

‘Guvernance’ and the ‘role’ of law: Getting the vowels right

Discussion started on 02 Mar 2017, 11:09 AM

 

The 2017 World Development Report on Governance and the Law (WDR 2017) has a very important message,[i] with some even hailing it as a game-changing document. It certainly reads differently to what one might expect from a World Bank report. Not only does it assess the economic drivers and consequences of poor governance and shaky rule of law, it also strays into the realm of the political, encouraging practitioners and donors to eschew many traditionally- accepted ‘best practices’, towards approaches that explicitly challenge the power structures that perpetuate poor governance and unresponsive institutions.

The report highlights the need for interventions to be contextually appropriate by focusing clearly on addressing problems specific to each society, and to ensure that institutional functions are prioritised over form. It also stresses the importance of being politically smart, cognisant of local norms and rules, and recommends being more realistic and committed to long-term incremental improvements.

In doing so, the report confirms much of what many have been saying for a while. But the value of this report lies not just in what is said, but that the World Bank is saying it. The fact that the Bank is talking about the role of power and politics at all is an important development, and one that we should welcome. This report calls for the international community, including the Bank itself, to pay greater attention to collaborative action aimed at supporting policies and systems that promote just and inclusive governance. As such, it is closely aligned to Goal 16 within the Agenda 2030 framework.

However, despite this change in thinking, the report seems oddly outdated on the role of law in relation to governance.

Two steps forward, one step back

I’m a rule of law person (not in the same way, but for the same reasons as Martin Krygier[ii]). That is the chief reason I’m taking issue with the WDR 2017. The report consistently emphasises the role of law, not the rule of law – and it is not a typo.

While the WDR ultimately acknowledges that the rule of law is needed for a country to realise its full social and economic potential, it poses some questions about efforts to strengthen the rule of law from a temporal point of view. In a suspiciously terse section on ‘Getting to the Rule of Law’, Gordon Brown, the former British Prime Minister is quoted as saying: “In establishing the rule of law, the first five centuries are always the hardest.” While this is a witty remark, it is not necessarily true (and objectively false with regards to the development of the rule of law in the UK). Presumably, the history of democracy and other highly contested concepts would also be subject to similar 500-year development assessments? As such, it is unclear what this temporal observation means for those involved in supporting the development of the rule of law.

The WDR 2017 does, however, suggest that in order to achieve the rule of law, “countries must first strengthen the different roles of law to enhance contestability, change incentives, and reshape preferences—that is, think not only about the rule of law but also about the role of law.

This shift of focus can help ‘free’ us from technocratic fixes and the traps of isomorphic mimicry. But this seems to be a strange call for the strange times in which we are living. There is very little evidence to support the idea that you have to do anything ‘first’ in order to achieve rule of law. In fact, I suggest we forget sequencing. Rule of law is not a binary achievement, but a constantly changing process. The ‘level’ of rule of law can, in a single country, differ in relation to a myriad of policy issues and political challenges, external and internal threats and so on.  Furthermore, developing a better understanding of the role of law, as one institution among others, does not in any way exclude rule of law. Debates around the rule of law rest on the fundamental notion that all power must be exercised in accordance with public and transparent rules. In the international context, the most authoritative definition is the so-called ‘UN definition’. This reflects how the concept has evolved in legal and political theory – that is, as a principle of governance for minimising arbitrary power by providing clear rules for how power should be exercised, changed and contested. Thus understood, a rule of law system is desirable in its own right and on its own merits.

Understanding rule and role together

Still, drawing our attention to the role of law is a laudable aim. Development actors have gradually and painstakingly come to learn that there is more to the law than just ‘the law’. That is, the law should be understood as being just one institution among others for affecting change, and that it can be used and abused for different purposes. We should acknowledge that law plays many different functions or roles in society. Mainstream development policy has not always reflected this. Too often, programmes have attempted to use technical legal reforms to address inherently political problems - with little success.

At the same time, there are some good examples where law has been employed as an arena for contestability – for enhancing commitment to new rules, or for coordination and cooperation between different interests, for example – but they are not always found in the mainstream rule of law and development work.

There is much to learn from the accumulated experience and knowledge of those working in the stream of feminist institutionalism,[iii] for example, where confronting political resistance, informal rules dictating power sharing and cultural and social opposition to reform agendas has been the norm. Feminist thinkers and activists have been able to develop politically smart programming, using a variety of strategies to effect transformative change. As Chapelle and Waylan assert, in order to understand “why and how gendered rules, norms and practice change or stay the same…we need to look within political organisations, to the operation of formal and the often invisible informal rules”.[iv]

This shows that there is an intrinsic value in the rule of law, even in the most thin or formal conception. And perhaps now more than ever, that value matters. Getting political leaders and others in power to play by established rules is no small feat, particularly considering recent trends where populism and authoritarian movements have been increasingly pushing into the formal political arena. Cannibalising on Krygier’s poignant remark, ‘repressive law is perhaps less terrible than lawless repression, but it can be terrible all the same’[v].

A step in the right direction?

The role of law that WDR 2017 brings our attention to is highly instrumental. It is law as an instrument for action, for implementing public policy, for securing bargains between elite players, or for breaking political deadlocks. That might be the role of law as an institution among others for affecting change. But it is worthwhile to remember that law, and in particular the rule of law, is not just about change but also about getting change right – ensuring it is inclusive, conflict sensitive, understood and actionable. Here, perhaps, Gordon Brown’s remark on the temporal feature of ‘getting’ the rule of law finds its place.

So I welcome the WDR, but I’m not sure it takes us anywhere we weren’t already going – and perhaps even takes us away from some areas we should be. Indeed the rule of law, through its network of principles and institutions, serves the purpose of checking political action, slowing things down if need be, and of resisting quick fixes. That’s just one of its roles – and now more than ever it’s one that seems to be lacking.

Richard Sannerholm works at the Swedish Expert Group for Aid Studies. He was previously the Head of Rule of Law at the Folke Bernadotte Academy, a Swedish agency for peace, security and development. Richard has extensive experience in public management reform, strategic research develpment, and from different rule of law and security projects and programmes. Richard holds a PhD in law and has published widely on rule of law and public administration reform in peacebuilding and development.

___

[i] World Bank, Governance and the Law, World Development Report 2017, 2017.

[ii] Krygier, ’Still a Rule of Law Guy’, Recht der Werkelijkheid 34:1, 2013)

[iii] Sannerholm, Quinn & Rabus, Responsive and Responsible: Politically Smart Rule of Law Reform in Conflict and Fragile States, 2016, p.72

[iv] Chappell & Waylen, ‘Gender and the Hidden Life of Institutions’, Public Administration Vol. 9, No. 1, 599-615, 2013 p. 603.

[v] Krygier, ‘Marxism and the Rule of Law: Reflections After the Collapse of Communism’, Law and Social Inquiry, 1990, p. 641.

13 replies Write your reply

Profile picture of Willow

Reply posted by
Willow

Reply posted on 03 Mar 2017, 01:59 PM

Politics is the rules which ought to be trailed by the People of that country. According to the expert of Custom Dissertation the Politics is only the Ideology through which the Citizen of that Country ought to take after.

Profile picture of jhonsmith

Reply posted by
jhonsmith

Reply posted on 20 Jun 2017, 12:31 PM

Richard Sannerholm works at the Swedish Expert Group for Aid Studies. He was beforehand the Head of Rule of Law at the Folke Bernadotte Academy, a Swedish office for peace, security and improvement. Richard has broad involvement out in the open administration change, vital research develpment, and from various run of law and security activities and projects. UK Essay Help Richard holds a PhD in law and has distributed broadly on lead of law and open organization change in peacebuilding and improvement.

Profile picture of Roger Jack

Reply posted by
Roger Jack

ABC

Reply posted on 01 Jul 2017, 10:56 AM

Short vowels and their sounds are frequently troublesome for battling perusers. For understudies who are powerless on vowel sound separation, spelling tests are torment. It takes after that perusing is hard for them also. Helpful Links for Students The law is essential since it goes about as a rule with reference to what is acknowledged in the public arena. Without it there would be clashes between social gatherings and groups. It is urgent that we tail them. The law takes into account simple selection to changes that happen in the general public.

Profile picture of J B

Reply posted by
J B

Reply posted on 03 Jul 2017, 08:17 AM

A student who learn about Law shuold know about the guvernance and the role of law. You get many book on this topic but you need to research on it. You need to go library and search related books. best personal statement writing service

Profile picture of alok

Reply posted by
alok

gm

Reply posted on 03 Jul 2017, 02:16 PM

It may be very onerous to mention once exactly ought to be pressured to cash your test.

unitedcheckcashing.com

Profile picture of jowpxzf001 jowpxzf001

Reply posted by
jowpxzf001 jowpxzf001

Reply posted on 06 Jul 2017, 03:52 AM

Whether you are looking for beach casual, business casual, evening attire or any other style that you can think of, Ralph Lauren has it to offer. Each store displays current trends of clothing line that are most popular and in season. Following the line of trend and yet remaining unique is what they does best and has made them the guru of men's fashion.. Der Umsatz belief sich auf 4,35 Mrd. US-Dollar. Investoren warten jetzt auf den 31. Für das Wertpapier von Michael Kors steht gegenwärtig ein Wertanstieg 1,48 Prozent zu Buche. Die Aktie verteuerte sich um 52 Cent. Derzeit zahlen Anleger an der Börse für das Papier 35,61 US-Dollar. It louboutin basket femme is no wonder that men desire the sophisticated and yet down to earth style over any other. It is also no surprise that they would tell their friends where to shop when they are in need of great michael kors geldbörse attire for any event, season or lifestyle. Be the best dressed man at the party, the beach or at work when you shop Ralph Lauren.. Ralph Lauren clothing line provides innovative quality into every seam of their clothing line provided for men both, both business and casual. Beginning with ties forty years ago, the company has grown to be a world wide provider of top of the line polos, chinos, dress borse michael kors attire, jeans, suits and more. Whether you are shopping in stores or online, you are taken into the world of Ralph polo ralph lauren Lauren at a level like no other.. So folgt auf Platz vier die Kelly-Bag von Hermès, auf fünf die 2.55 von Chanel, michael kors borse danach die City-Bag von Balenciaga, Boy von Chanel, die Neverfull von Louis Vuitton. Die komplette Liste samt Taschen-Fakten für den Mode-Smalltalk gibt es hier. Richtig überraschend ist unter all den sicheren Nummern von Gucci, Céline, Dior & Co. In totale raggiungerà louboutin pas cher femme 39 paesi in America, Europa e Asia. NEW YORK, 15 SET - Romantica e forte allo stesso tempo: una Barbara Stanwyck, orfana a 4 anni che nel 1944 louboutin soldes divenne la donna più pagata d'America, o una Kim Basinger per guardare michael kors bags uk sale più vicino a noi, sono le muse michael kors outlet che ha avuto in mente Michael Kors nei sei mesi in borsa michael kors cui ha disegnato la sua prossima collezione non più pensata per la primavera-estate, ne' per l'autunno-inverno, ma per un mondo "molto complicato" e "sempre più difficile, un mondo pieno di drammi e paure e in cui non esistono più' le louboutin pas cher stagioni. Un ottimista per indole, lo stilista americano e' convinto che, anche in questo mondo, "la moda può cambiare il tuo spirito" e michael kors taschen agisce e disegna di conseguenza. Val Garland, visionario make up artist, ha applicato sulla bocca michael kors outlet delle modelle delle rose essiccate michael kors bags outlet che mimano il rossetto, fiordalisi sopra le guance e fiori di campo sul décolleté. Ritorna anche l'eye liner a fiori, proposto l'anno scorso da una blogger norvegese con fiori disegnati a mano, questa primavera, invece, su Instagram sono apparsi degli occhi contornati da fiori veri, mini bouquet sopra la linea cheap ralph lauren shirts dell'eyeliner. Stranezze a parte, le palette trucco si rinnovano con motivi floreali decorati michael kors taschen sale sia sul pack sia direttamente sulle polveri.

Bis zum 15. Juli haben Interessenten die Möglichkeit, direkt im Laden, per E-Mail unter info@elbe-taschen.de oder auf der Facebook-Seite unter „Ahoi Stade“ ein Gebot abzugeben. Namen und E-Mail-Adresse nicht vergessen, damit der oder die Höchstbietende michael kors outlet benachrichtigt werden kann! Im Sommer 2015 wagte Carola Arndt-Vöge mit einer ungewöhnlichen Geschäftsidee den Sprung in michael kors portafogli die Selbstständigkeit. Vor zwei Jahren eröffnete Raumausstatterin Carola Arndt-Vöge ihr Fachgeschäft „AHOI - Planentaschen-Manufaktur und PolsterWerkstatt“ an der Kehdinger Straße 22 in Stade. Den Firmengeburtstag feiert sie mit zwei besonderen Aktionen. Zum einen gewährt sie zwischen dem 15. Und hoffentlich auch all jene zum Umdenken bewegen, die auf die „Gabrielle Bag“ von Chanel sparen. Habt Mut zur Maschine! Man will doch mit der Zeit gehen. Hermès hat den Ruf, die besten Taschen der Welt zu fertigen. In diesem Beitrag handelt es sich um eine It-Bag, die mit keiner anderen zu vergleichen ist! Die Rede ist von der neuen Tasche aus Jute mit Zara-Logo: Wie Marie Claire schon richtig erkannt hat, ist der Shopper perfekt für den Lebensmittel-Einkauf! Jetzt können müssen wir Plastik-Tüten endgültig vergessen: Anstatt christian louboutin chaussures femme die jedes Mal einzukaufen (so doof!), nehmen wir gleich die Jute-Tasche mit. Durch ihre Größe passt aber auch wirklich alles rein, inklusive Milch, Avocados, Pizza und was wir sonst noch alles lieben. Achtung, cheap polo ralph lauren outlet im folgenden Beitrag könnten akute Fernweh-Gefühle bei euch hochkommen. Ces 150 millions d'euros aideront Sigfox à déployer des réseaux mondiaux permettant de relier à internet toute une gamme d'objets connectés, allant des machines ralph lauren sale à laver aux compteurs électriques. Il est compatible avec le Wifi, la 2G ou la 3G. En février 2015, l'entreprise toulousaine, fondée en 2009 par l'entrepreneur Ludovic Le Moan, avait levé 100 millions d'euros, notamment auprès des groupes industriels français Engie et Air Liquide, de l'opérateur de télécommunications espagnol Telefonica, du japonais NTT Docomo et du sud-coréen SK Telecom, et de Bpifrance. Puntuale eco di primavera, il flower power ritorna. Fiori negli abiti, Michael Kors ha proposto un trench tutto fiorito, Valentino e Giambattista Valli hanno scelto preziosi ricami floreali su abiti chiari. Fiori nella tavola, nei quadri, Monet diceva «se sono diventato pittore, forse lo devo ai fiori», nella lettura e negli accessori, vedi le borse di Gucci con fiori simile-broccato e i michael kors uk decorati secchielli bucolici di Etro. Designer Michael Kors macht es vor. Während der Hippie-Zeit der 60er-Jahre wurde wohl keine Tasche mehr gefeiert als die Hobo-Bag. Und wir dürfen uns jetzt wieder freuen, denn die etwas größeren knautschigen Taschen sind zurück.

Realizzato da Arcus Real Estate, società della galassia Percassi, sarà aperto tutto l'anno tranne a Natale e Capodanno. Simbolo dell'Outlet Village un obelisco di 85 metri. "Dà lavoro a 600 persone, tra addetti alle vendite e store manager, mille con l'indotto, ma il numero raddoppierà con il completamento del progetto", sottolinea Antonio Percassi, presidente di louboutin homme pas cher Percassi. For years, male celebrities such as Lebron James, Lance Armstrong and Kevin Costner have raved about the christian louboutin soldes feel and look of the styles offered by Ralph Lauren. The great thing about this company is that you don't have to be a celebrity to dress like one. Many everyday people enjoy what Ralph Lauren has to offer their customers world wide. “Macy’s, Nordstrom, and Dillard’s DDS, +10.15% called out weakness in women’s accessories, with Nordstrom particularly noting softness in jewelry and handbags and higher-volume brands,” the note said. “Importantly, while Kate Spade (25%) and Coach (5%) have much more limited wholesale exposure, Michael Kors’ wholesale segment is much larger at 50% of total sales. Thus, Michael Kors is more exposed to the continued softening in this channel.”. Les nouveaux fonds levés par l'entreprise lui permettront de déployer son réseau international dans 60 pays ralph lauren australia d'ici 2018 contre 26 actuellement. Sigfox est en concurrence avec le réseau Jasper de l'américain Cisco. La startup se rémunère sur la vente de forfaits de connectivité aux industriels qui vont, selon les volumes, de 1 euro à 10 euros par objet et par an. Auch Bezüge borse michael kors prezzi von Judo- und Turnmatten sowie Bootsverdeckstoff dienen als Ausgangsstoff. „Die Taschen sind wasserdicht und strapazierfähig und äußerst vielfältig einsetzbar“, sagt cheap michael kors bags Carola Arndt-Vöge. „Das Spektrum reicht von kleinen Formaten zur Aufbewahrung von Stiften oder anderen Kleinigkeiten bis zu Rucksäcken und Umhängetaschen.“ Weiteres Standbein des Unternehmens ist die Polsterwerkstatt. Vor allem die Geschäfte in Europa und den USA liefen schlecht, teilte das für seine Handtaschen und Schuhe bekannte US-Unternehmen am Mittwoch mit. Das konnten Zuwächse in Asien nicht ausgleichen. Der Konzernumsatz sackte im ersten Quartal um rund elf Prozent auf 1,06 Milliarden Dollar ab. La Palette occhi dedicata è composta da 39 tonalità luminose, tra cui l’intera gamma dei nude, dei rosa e della pesca passando per i beige, i marroni, i talpa e i grigi da provare da sole o con la matita nera. Pretty Kisses (Dolci Baci) è un trio mini di fragranze in tonalità piccanti. Infine le perle da bagno profumate da spargere dentro all’acqua per un momento di relax.

Zieht man den S&P 500 als Benchmark hinzu, dann liegt die Aktie von Michael Kors vorn. Der S&P 500 kommt mit einem Punktestand von 2.437 Punkten derzeit auf ein Plus von michael kors tasche schwarz 0,07 Prozent gegenüber der Schlussnotierung vom Vortag. Die Michael Kors-Aktie hatte am 26. Ob in mädchenhaften Pastelltönen, glitzernd oder michael kors borse outlet elegant – diese Bags begeistern in völlig neuem LookDen Look der Stars online nachkaufen und sind damit nicht mehr nur michael kors bags on sale beim Wandern oder auf Festivals unsere Begleiter, sondern auch beim entspannten Stadtbummel total angesagt und ein absoluter Hingucker! Manchmal kommt es eben doch auf die Größe an. Neben XXS-Taschen werden wir in michael kors taschen outlet diesem Sommer auch übergroße Modelle zu sehen bekommen. Der sprichwörtlich große Vorteil: Wir christian louboutin chaussures pas cher müssen michael kors italia nicht überlegen, was wir mitnehmen wollen. Flight ralph lauren outlet australia Club a aidé à identifier les marques et les styles des chaussures. Nos confrères de Business Insider US ont fait de leur mieux pour trouver des photos de femmes qui portent des baskets, mais sans grand succès. Les femmes de pouvoir comme Sheryl Sandberg et Marissa Mayer portent des talons bas ou des chaussures basses. Die sorgt in polo ralph lauren outlet online der Modewelt seit einiger Zeit für Aufruhr: Ist der Plastikeinkaufstaschen-Look cooles Understatement, eine ironische Multikulti-Referenz – oder doch ein peinlicher Flirt mit dem einfachen Leben? Die Mini-„Bazar“ mit Umhängegurt passt jedenfalls perfekt zu gut situierten michael kors outlet uk Geizhälsen, die ständig von der tollen Qualität bei Lidl schwärmen und ihr Obst nur beim Türken um die Ecke kaufen. Um 645 Euro. Die angesagteste Taschenform der Saison möchte bitte nicht als „Beutel“ beschimpft, sondern „Cinch Bag“ genannt werden. fashionette michael kors Il profumo di carte artigianali tipiche fiorentine invadono i piccoli vicoli della città andando a michael kors handbags uk fondersi con odori di pelli conciate delle antiche botteghe. Florentia, cattura l’essenza di rosa speziata, legno e cuoio e li unisce a oli essenziali di bergamotto italiano, patchouli, vetiver indonesiani e mirra della Somalia, un mix caldo e ambrato, tutte materie prime naturali che arrivano dal mondo: bergamotto d’Italia, essenza di Gaiac del Paraguay, mirra della Somalia, essenza di vetiver dell’Indonesia, bacche rosa dell’Isola di Reunion, essenza ralph lauren polo shirts sale di Coriandolo. La texture associata alla fragranza ricorda le michael kors handtaschen outlet preziose carte fiorentine. Die Stepptasche „Timeless“ von Chanel, die „Speedy“ von Louis Vuitton, die „Birkin“ von Hermès: Das sind die drei Handtaschen, die im Vintage-Onlineshop Vestiaire Collective am häufigsten weiterverkauft werden. Dies ergab eine Rangliste, die der Shop jüngst veröffentlichte. Auch beim Rest der 25 beliebtesten Modelle handelt sich weitestgehend um Handtaschen-Klassiker der großen Marken, um Modelle, deren Anschaffung viele Frauen mit der Erklärung begründen, sie kämen ja nicht so schnell aus der Mode und seien regelrechte Investitionen in die modische Zukunft.HMM20170610

Profile picture of Andrew Lowe

Reply posted by
Andrew Lowe

Reply posted on 18 Jul 2017, 11:58 AM

Hey! I was looking for the online academic help here and now I am really interested in this topic! I am going to enter the law faculty so I really appreciate your post 

Profile picture of Ryker

Reply posted by
Ryker

manager

Reply posted on 31 Jul 2017, 11:40 AM

Excellent and nice article. when user want to get important information then visit our site.

Free Hitman Pro Product Key

Profile picture of alok

Reply posted by
alok

gm

Reply posted on 02 Aug 2017, 08:36 AM

Are you trying to money right into a financial institution account, the whole quantity commonly cannot be immediately accessed; there could also be a waiting amount for the check to clean?

check cashing near me

Profile picture of alok

Reply posted by
alok

gm

Reply posted on 10 Sep 2017, 08:12 AM

We generally tend to truly like to oblige you the only matters with one hundred percentage agreements and faster ever.

unitedcheckcashing.com

Write your reply:

In order to join this discussion you need to
log in or register.

Subscribe to our monthly newsletter